News
marketing

Cut the Rent or Offer a Free Month: Pricing a Slow Vacancy

A rent cut and a free month can cost about the same in year one and never again. One free month on a 12-month lease is a discount of 8.3 per cent, and in Ontario your lawful rent survives the incentive only when it is written as whole rent-free months.

The two levers have different shapes

A rent cut changes the number in the lease. Every month after that is lower, and so is the base you raise from at renewal. An incentive leaves the number alone and hands back value once: a free month, parking included for the term, a waived locker fee, a moving credit. The lease still says the higher figure.

That difference decides the question. One lever is permanent and one is temporary, so comparing them on the asking price tells you nothing. Compare them on what you collect.

Put both options on one basis

Net effective rent is the total you collect over the term divided by the number of months in the term. It is the number that makes a cut and an incentive comparable.

Take a one-bedroom asking $1,900 a month on a 12-month lease.

  • Cut to $1,800. You collect $21,600. Net effective rent is $1,800, a discount of 5.3 per cent.
  • Hold $1,900 and give one month free. You collect $20,900. Net effective rent is $1,742, a discount of 8.3 per cent.

One free month on a one-year term is always a discount of one twelfth, or 8.3 per cent. That is deeper than the cut most people reach for, which is the first thing the arithmetic tells you. In year one it costs $700 more than the $100 cut.

Year two reverses the order. Suppose your province allows a 2.5 per cent increase. The cut unit goes to $1,845 and collects $22,140. The incentive unit raises from $1,900 to $1,947.50 and collects $23,370. The incentive is $1,230 ahead for that year, which clears the $700 it gave up and leaves you $530 better off across the two years. The gap widens every year after that, because the cut lowered the base you compound from. Real caps for next year are set out in the 2027 rent increase caps.

Price the waiting as well. At $1,900 a month, an empty unit costs about $62 a day. One free month is worth $1,900, so the incentive pays for itself if it fills the unit roughly a month sooner than holding out at full price would.

Ontario leaves the face rent alone, but only in certain shapes

In Ontario the shape of the incentive decides whether your rent survives it. Section 111 of the Residential Tenancies Act says the lawful rent is not affected by a discount of up to three months rent in any 12-month period when the discount is given in the form of rent-free periods and meets the prescribed conditions. Ontario Regulation 516/06 sets those conditions: the discount has to be in a written agreement, and where rent is monthly, each month of discount has to be taken inside one rental period.

Two further written-agreement discounts are prescribed and leave the lawful rent alone. One caps the total given in the first eight months of the 12-month period at one month of rent. The other allows up to two months across the 12-month period, with no more than one month of it in the first seven and any later discount confined to a single month.

Anything outside those shapes falls under subsection 111(3), and the regulation then averages the discount into your lawful rent. Take $100 off every month and the averaged figure becomes the rent you are permitted to charge and the base you raise from. You have made a rent cut and called it an incentive. Prompt payment has its own rule: a discount of up to 2 per cent for paying on or before the due date leaves the lawful rent alone, and a larger one sets the lawful rent at the discounted rent divided by 0.98.

The working version of all that: write the incentive as whole rent-free months, name the months, keep it in the written agreement, and do not convert it into a lower monthly figure.

Four criteria that settle the call

  1. How long you expect to hold the unit. The incentive wins over time, because its advantage arrives at renewal. If you are selling the property or taking the unit back inside a year, the cut is the cheaper lever and the lawful rent question never comes up.
  2. Whether your rent increases are capped on the rent charged. Where they are, a cut lowers the ceiling for every year you own the building, not one year.
  3. Whether price is the problem at all. Count enquiries, then count applications. Enquiries arriving with no applications behind them points at the showing, the screening or the photos, and no price lever fixes that. Two useful companions here are why reach does not fix a low enquiry rate and the two clocks running on an empty unit.
  4. What a lender or buyer will underwrite. A cut reduces net operating income, and at any capitalization rate the value follows it down. An incentive keeps the rent roll intact, which helps, though appraisers and lenders often underwrite effective rent rather than face rent, so treat the protection as partial. Before you assume the rent roll carries the day, check what belongs in net operating income.

When the cut is the right answer

  • The unit is mispriced rather than slow. If your figure sits above the comparable units in the neighbourhood, an incentive buys one lease and the vacancy comes back next year. Check your benchmark first: average rent is not market rent.
  • You needed an incentive last year too. A face rent that fills only with a giveaway, every single time, is not a market rent. It is a number you are defending.
  • You want this tenant to renew. A tenant who moved in on a free month meets a full-price year two. The jump they feel is the incentive coming off, and it reads like an increase nobody warned them about. Say what year two costs while they are signing, not eleven months later.

What to write down

  • The face rent, as the rent in the lease.
  • The incentive, described as whole rent-free months, with the calendar months named.
  • The term, and the date the first increase can take effect.
  • The net effective rent you calculated, kept in your own file, so next year's vacancy has something to be measured against.

Then advertise the rent you will charge, with the incentive stated next to it rather than folded into a lower headline number. Ontario's rules on what the advertised price has to include are covered in mandatory fees and the advertised rent.


Back to all articles