News
marketing

The Parking Myth: A Stall You Provide Is Inside the Rent

A parking stall or storage locker you provide counts as a service or facility under both the Ontario and BC tenancy Acts, so its value sits inside the rent whether or not you itemized it. That makes withdrawing it a rent reduction, and the amount depends on how the spot got there.

Under both Ontario's Residential Tenancies Act and British Columbia's Residential Tenancy Act, a parking stall or storage locker you provide to a tenant is a service or facility, and the money you collect for it is rent. That holds whether you broke it out on its own line or folded it into one number.

The consequence catches landlords out in both directions. You cannot start charging for a spot a tenant already has. And when you want the spot back, the province decides what that costs you, using a rule that is harder on landlords who never charged for it.

The myth: parking is a separate agreement

The belief is reasonable on its face. Parking often sits on its own line, sometimes on its own piece of paper, so it feels like a contract beside the tenancy, repriced or cancelled on its own terms.

The Acts do not read it that way. Ontario's definition of rent covers consideration paid for the right to occupy a unit "and for any services and facilities and any privilege, accommodation or thing that the landlord provides," then adds the clause that settles the argument: "whether or not a separate charge is made." The list of services and facilities in the same section names parking and related facilities, and storage facilities. British Columbia lands in the same place, with near-identical wording.

You cannot put a price on a spot the tenant already has

In Ontario, section 134 prohibits requiring a tenant to pay "any consideration for goods or services as a condition for granting the tenancy or continuing to permit occupancy" where that consideration is on top of the lawful rent. A stall that came with the unit is already paid for by the rent. Billing for it next month is an additional charge, and the Board can order the money back.

There is a lawful route, and it is narrower than it sounds. Section 123 lets you increase the rent at any time if the tenant agrees that you will add a parking space. It operates despite the 90 day notice rule, and an increase under it is deemed not to be an increase for the 12 month rule, so it is one of the few Ontario rent increases that can happen mid-year and outside the guideline. But it only reaches a spot the tenant does not already have, and section 124 voids the agreement if it came from coercion or from a misleading representation by you or your agent.

Taking the spot back costs more if you never charged for it

A tenant who loses a service can apply to the Board under section 130 for a rent reduction. The order takes effect on the day the discontinuance first occurred rather than the day of the hearing, and the tenant has a year from that day to file.

How far the rent drops depends on how the parking got there. Ontario Regulation 516/06 sets two different rules:

  • Added under a section 123 agreement. The reduction equals the most recent amount of the separate charge. You charged 75 dollars a month, you give back 75 dollars a month, and your downside is capped at the number you picked.
  • Bundled in from the start. The reduction is a reasonable charge based on your cost. Where the cost cannot be determined or there is no cost, it falls back to the value of the facility, "including the cost to the tenant or former tenant of replacing the discontinued service or facility."

Read that second rule against a real market. A painted line on asphalt you already own has close to no cost to you, so the benchmark becomes the monthly rate at the nearest commercial lot, which in a dense neighbourhood sits well above anything you would have charged. If the Board finds the discontinuance was not reasonable, the regulation adds the effect on the tenant on top and treats that reasonable-charge figure as a floor.

So the asymmetry runs against instinct. Itemizing parking under a proper section 123 agreement caps what withdrawing it can cost you later. Folding it quietly into the rent leaves that number open, and the tenant's replacement cost is what sets it.

British Columbia: 30 days, the right form, and two things you cannot cut

Section 27 says you must not terminate or restrict a service or facility at all if it is essential to the tenant's use of the unit as living accommodation, or if providing it is a material term of the tenancy agreement. For anything outside those two categories you may cut it, provided you give 30 days written notice in the approved form, the Residential Tenancy Branch's form RTB-24, and reduce the rent by an amount equivalent to the reduction in the value of the tenancy.

Where parking falls is a question of fact. Policy Guideline 22 defines an essential service as one that is "necessary, indispensable, or fundamental," and asks whether a reasonable person would find that losing it makes the unit impractical to live in. It also directs the arbitrator to weigh whether the tenant can obtain a reasonable substitute, which is where a building with street parking and a building without it part company. One point sits in the landlord's favour: on a claim that a service was cut without an adequate rent reduction, the burden of proof is on the tenant.

Four checks before you change anything

  1. Find out whether the spot is named in the tenancy. Read the signed agreement, every addendum, and any email that promised a stall. Separate paper does not make a separate deal.
  2. Check whether a separate charge was ever taken. In Ontario that one fact decides which valuation rule applies, so pull the rent ledger.
  3. Price the withdrawal before you announce it. Get the monthly rate at the two nearest commercial lots. In Ontario that is the figure a tenant will put in front of the Board; in BC it is most of the substitute question.
  4. Decide the structure on the next lease, not this one. If you may want the stall back one day, keep it out of the base rent and add it under its own agreement with a stated monthly charge, so the reduction on withdrawal is capped there. If parking is what makes the unit rentable, bundle it and plan to keep providing it as long as the tenancy runs.

Either way, write down which stall. "One parking space" and "stall 14" are different promises, and only one of them lets you reorganize the lot without touching anybody's tenancy.


Back to all articles