News
operations

The Landlord Insurance Playbook: Seven Checks on a Renewal Offer

The Insurance Bureau of Canada states it plainly: whether you rent a property out, short or long term, must be disclosed to your insurer, and failing to do so can void your coverage. Here are seven checks to run on a rental property renewal offer before you pay it.

A rental property insurance renewal arrives as a premium and a payment date. The decisions that matter sit on the declaration page behind it, and most of them were set once and copied forward every year since.

This is the pass to make before you pay. It takes about twenty minutes with the renewal offer, the declaration page and the policy wording in front of you. It is written for landlords holding one to twenty doors, where there is no risk manager and the broker hears from you only when something breaks.

1. Confirm the policy covers the property as rented to others

This is the check that can undo all the others. The Insurance Bureau of Canada lists owner occupied, rented to others, and recreational or seasonal as separate policy types, and says that how often a property is used and whether you rent it out, short or long term, must be disclosed to your insurer. Its guidance on the consequence is one sentence long: contact your insurer first, because failing to do so can void your coverage.

Find the line on the declaration page that describes occupancy. If it says owner occupied and a tenant has been living there for two years, stop working through this list and call the broker today. The same goes for a basement suite you started renting, a unit that moved from annual leases to nightly stays, and a property you used to live in yourself.

2. Read the coverage level, then read the perils list

Canadian property policies come in levels, and the level decides how the wording works. IBC describes comprehensive as covering the building and its contents for all risks except those specifically excluded, and basic or named perils as covering only those perils that are specifically stated. Broad and no frills sit between them.

If the policy is named perils, the list is the coverage. Read the whole list. A landlord who assumes comprehensive and holds named perils learns the difference during a claim, which is the most expensive moment to learn it.

3. Check the building limit against rebuild cost

The building limit should be what it costs to rebuild the structure, not what the property would sell for. IBC notes that the replacement value of a building may differ from both market value and the municipal tax assessment, and in most Canadian markets it differs in the direction that hurts.

Two questions here. When was the rebuild cost last calculated rather than indexed by a percentage? And does the policy carry a co-insurance clause? A co-insurance clause ties what you recover on a partial loss to how close your limit sits to full value, so if one is in the wording, get the percentage in writing.

4. Buy water coverage on purpose

Water is where the gap usually sits, because the two coverages landlords most often assume are included are both optional purchases. IBC states that basement water damage from a sewer backup is only covered if you have purchased specific, optional sewer backup coverage, and that flood coverage is optional as well.

Three things to confirm: whether sewer backup is on this policy, whether overland water is on this policy, and the limit on each. Either can carry its own limit well below the building limit, and the lower number is the one that pays.

5. Find the rental income limit and how long it runs

Loss of rental income replaces the rent a damaged unit stops producing. Two numbers decide whether it helps: the limit, and the period it runs for.

Ask the broker to confirm in writing whether the coverage pays a dollar amount or a number of months, what starts the clock, and what ends it. A gutted unit with a nine-month restoration and a three-month limit is a six-month hole you cover yourself.

One correction worth making while you are in this section: this coverage responds to physical damage the policy covers. A tenant who stops paying is an arrears problem, not a claim.

6. Find the vacancy clock before your next turnover

Every property policy sets a limit on how long a building can sit empty before the coverage changes or stops. The threshold varies by insurer and by wording, so the number in your policy is the only one worth knowing. Find it, write it on the turnover checklist, and count from the day the last tenant hands back the keys.

While you are in that section, note what the policy asks of you during a vacancy. Heat maintained, water shut off or lines drained, and inspections at some interval are the common requirements. A long make-ready in January is the usual way a landlord crosses that line without noticing.

7. Check the names

The named insured has to match who holds title. Four things drift here over a few years:

  • The property moved into a corporation or a holding company and the policy still names a person.
  • A co-owner was added or removed.
  • An owner died and an estate now holds title.
  • The mortgage was refinanced with a new lender and the old mortgagee is still listed.

If a management company collects the rent, check whether the management agreement requires it to be named as an additional insured, and whether it is.

The email to send

Most landlords cannot answer all seven questions from the paperwork alone. That is normal. Copy the ones you could not answer, paste them under your policy number, and ask for replies by email so the renewal file holds a written record.

  • What occupancy is on file for this property, and does the policy cover it as rented to others?
  • What coverage level is this, and can you send me the perils list?
  • When was the rebuild cost last calculated rather than indexed? Is there a co-insurance clause, and at what percentage?
  • Is sewer backup on this policy? Is overland water on this policy? What is the limit on each?
  • What is the rental income limit, is it a dollar figure or a period, and what starts and ends it?
  • How many consecutive days can the building sit empty before coverage changes, and what does the policy require of me during that time?
  • Who is the named insured and who is the mortgagee, and are both current?

Send it before the renewal date. A gap you find this week is a conversation with a broker. The same gap found during a claim is a number you absorb yourself.


Back to all articles