News
marketing

The Guarantor Myth: A Co-Signer Is a Tenant and a Guarantor Is Not

British Columbia puts it in writing: a co-signer signs the tenancy agreement, a guarantor signs a separate one, and the director has no jurisdiction over guarantors. That single difference decides whether you collect at the tribunal or in court.

A co-signer and a guarantor are two different promises, and the difference decides which forum can order the money paid. One signature goes on the tenancy agreement. The other goes on a separate document that points at it. Landlords tend to find out which one they took after the arrears are real.

The myth

The myth is that adding a parent or an employer to a lease gives you a second person to pursue, and that the word on the signature line is a formality. Co-signer, guarantor, co-applicant: the belief is that you have doubled your security whichever one you wrote.

What you picked was the document. The document decides whether your claim belongs to the tenancy tribunal or to a court, and one of the two choices hands the signer a right to live in the unit.

The two definitions

British Columbia puts both in writing. Residential Tenancy Policy Guideline 27 (July 2024) defines a co-signer as a person who "signs the tenancy agreement along with the tenant to guarantee the tenant performs the tenancy agreement, e.g., pays rent." A guarantor is a person who "signs a separate agreement with the landlord" to guarantee the same thing.

That is the whole distinction, and it turns on paperwork rather than intent. Both people mean to stand behind the rent. Only one is a party to the tenancy agreement.

Why the document decides the forum

Guideline 27 states the consequence in the next breath. The director "has jurisdiction to resolve disputes between co-signers and landlords because they are parties to the tenancy agreement," and "has no jurisdiction to resolve disputes between landlords and guarantors, however, because they are not parties to the tenancy agreement."

A co-signer sits inside the dispute resolution process. A guarantor sits outside it, and a claim against a guarantor is an ordinary contract claim heard by a court.

Ontario reaches the same split through its statute. The Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 defines a tenant as a person who pays rent in return for the right to occupy a rental unit. A guarantor has no right to occupy and pays nothing for one. Section 168(2) gives the Landlord and Tenant Board exclusive jurisdiction over applications under the Act, and those applications run between landlords and tenants. A guarantee is a promise made outside that relationship, which is why a landlord enforcing one is headed for court rather than the Board.

The ceilings are different too

Both routes have a cap, and the caps are not the same number.

  • In Ontario, section 207(1) of the Act lets the Board order payment up to the greater of $10,000 and the monetary jurisdiction of the Small Claims Court. That maximum is $50,000 under Ontario Regulation 626/00, so the Board's ceiling tracks it.
  • In British Columbia, the director cannot decide a debt or damages claim above the Small Claims Act limit, which Guideline 27 gives as $35,000. Above that you go to the BC Supreme Court, or abandon the excess and keep the rest at the branch.

On one unit these ceilings seldom bind. On a student house with four bedrooms, a year of arrears plus turnover damage can reach them.

Ontario's standard lease has no line for either one

Form 2229E is required for tenancies entered into on March 1, 2021 or later. Section 1, Parties to the Agreement, gives fields for Landlord(s) and Tenant(s) and nothing else. The form carries no guarantor field, no co-signer field, and a note that all of its sections are mandatory and cannot be changed.

Section 15 is where additional terms go, and the form is blunt about the limit on them: an additional term "cannot take away a right or responsibility under the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006." Section 15 also speaks to what the landlord and the tenant must do, and a guarantor is neither. The cleaner route is a separate guarantee that identifies the lease by address and date, names the obligations covered, and is signed by the guarantor. Have it reviewed where the sum at stake is large.

Naming them a tenant is not the free option

You can put the parent in Section 1 and make them a tenant. That does bring them inside the Board's reach. It also gives them the rest of what a tenant holds.

  • A right to occupy. A person named as a tenant can move in. They are not an unauthorized occupant and you cannot treat them as one.
  • A right to be served. Notices and applications have to name and reach every tenant, so you have added a required recipient to every arrears notice, every rent increase notice and every hearing package.
  • A right to apply against you. Tenant applications are open to them on the same terms.

The liability also runs further than most co-signers expect. Guideline 13 (May 2024) makes co-tenants jointly and severally responsible for rent, and usually for debts and damages, so a landlord "can recover the full amount of rent, utilities or any damages owing from all or any one of the tenants." A co-signer on a four-bedroom house does not owe a quarter of the rent. They owe the whole rent. Say that at signing instead of at collection.

What to do before the next lease

  1. Pick the outcome first. If you want a tribunal order against the person, they have to be a tenant on the agreement. If you want them off the tenancy and you accept a court claim, take a guarantee.
  2. Match the document to the choice. A tenant goes in the parties section. A guarantor goes in a separate signed guarantee that references the lease. Writing "guarantor" beside a name in the tenant block does neither job.
  3. Describe the term you are covering. If the guarantee is meant to carry through a renewal or a month-to-month continuation, say so in the document. Silence on that point is a decision you made without noticing.
  4. Collect the guarantor's own address and identification. A guarantee you cannot serve is a guarantee you cannot enforce.
  5. Check whose rules you are under. The BC guidelines are policy, persuasive at the Residential Tenancy Branch and not legislation anywhere else.

The short version

A co-signer is a tenant: a right to the keys, and liability for the whole rent. A guarantor is a contract with someone who will never hold the keys, enforced in court. Both have their uses. The expensive mistake is choosing between them by accident, because the choice is made by which document gets signed, not by the word written above the line.


Back to all articles