News
marketing

Repair or Replace: Deciding on One Broken Appliance in a Rental Unit

A broken fridge or water heater is two decisions, not one: how long provincial law gives you, and whether the repair buys enough remaining life to beat replacing it. Four criteria settle it, and one of them is that the CRA treats the two choices differently.

A failed appliance in a tenanted unit is two decisions stacked on each other. The first is how long you have, which provincial law sets and you do not get to negotiate. The second is whether a repair buys enough remaining service life to beat a replacement, which is arithmetic you control. This is aimed at landlords holding one to a dozen scattered units, where nothing gets replaced on a schedule.

Settle the clock before you price anything

Ontario's maintenance standards require that appliances supplied by the landlord "shall be maintained in a good state of repair and in a safely operable condition", and the regulation defines appliances to include refrigerators, stoves, clothes washers, clothes dryers, dishwashers and hot water tanks (O. Reg. 517/06, s. 40). A hot water tank is an appliance under that standard, not a building system you can treat as a slow project. Those standards apply where no municipal property standards bylaw covers the complex, and in prescribed circumstances where one does, so read your bylaw too. Section 20 of the Act sits above them and holds even if the tenant knew before signing, so a clause saying the tenant accepts the appliances as they are changes nothing.

Then separate the vital services from everything else. Hot or cold water, fuel, electricity and gas are vital services all year, and heat is one from September 1 to June 15 (O. Reg. 516/06, s. 4(1)). A landlord cannot withhold the reasonable supply of a vital service (Act, s. 21(1)). A dead fridge in July and a dead furnace in November are not the same decision, even when the invoice matches.

British Columbia draws a second line worth borrowing. Section 33 of the Residential Tenancy Act lists the failures that count as emergency repairs: the primary heating system, the electrical systems, major leaks in pipes or the roof, blocked water or sewer pipes, and damaged locks. On those, a tenant who has twice tried your emergency contact and then waited a reasonable time can have the work done and bill you (s. 33(3) and s. 33(5)). There the choice is not repair or replace. It is handling it, or having it handled at a price you never approved.

Criterion one: cost per year of service bought

The shortcut you will hear is to repair when the repair costs less than half of a replacement. It leaves out the number that decides the question: how much life the repair buys. Divide each option by the years of service you expect from it.

A 340 dollar control board on a fourteen-year-old fridge that plausibly carries it three more years costs about 113 dollars a year. An 1,100 dollar replacement you expect to run twelve years costs about 92 dollars a year. The repair is a third of the price and the more expensive choice. Change that first figure to a 120 dollar thermostat and the repair wins outright. Use your own history for the years-you-expect number.

Criterion two: the CRA treats the two choices differently

A repair and a replacement do not land in the same place on your return, and the gap is wide enough to flip a close call. The CRA's rental income guide frames the test as questions: does the expense give a lasting benefit, does it maintain the property or improve it beyond its original condition, is it for a part of a property or for a separate asset, and were the repairs made to sell the asset. The value of the expense is a tiebreaker.

In practice, fixing a part is generally a current expense, deductible against this year's rental income. Replacing a separate asset is generally capital, which puts it in a capital cost allowance class and returns it over years. Appliances and furniture sit in Class 8 at 20 per cent, the building usually in Class 1 at 4 per cent, and the half-year rule normally limits you, in the year you add the asset, to CCA on half your net additions.

An 1,100 dollar fridge is therefore not an 1,100 dollar deduction this year. You also cannot use CCA to create a rental loss, so the claim is capped at your net rental income before CCA. On a property already at break-even, a capital addition does nothing for you this year, while the same money spent on a qualifying repair reduces taxable income now. Price both paths after tax, not at the counter.

Criterion three: downtime, and where it lands

A repair that waits ten days on a part is not a repair. It is a breach with an invoice attached, and on a vital service it is the kind that gets decided against you. A replacement available tomorrow can win on timing while losing on price. Ask the supplier two things: is the part in stock locally, and is the model still supported. A discontinued control board tells you something about every other part in the cabinet.

Where the downtime lands depends on whether anyone is living there. With a tenant in place, entry has to be scheduled under its own notice rules (see the entry notice playbook). If the unit is empty and listed, downtime becomes days vacant, the interval that costs you rent (see days on market and days vacant).

Criterion four: who pays the utility

An efficient replacement saves money for whoever pays the bill. If the tenant pays the hydro, a lower-draw fridge is a retention and listing argument, not a line in your per-year math. If heat or hot water is included in the rent, the saving is yours and belongs in the comparison. Resist putting a figure on it without your own before-and-after bills.

When the decision makes itself

  • Safety. Heating systems, including stoves, heating appliances and chimneys, have to be in a good state of repair and in a safely operable condition (O. Reg. 517/06, s. 17). A cracked heat exchanger or scorched wiring is not a candidate for a holding repair.
  • The unit has dropped below the standard. Hot water has to reach at least 43 degrees Celsius as its ordinary temperature, and habitable space has to hold at least 20 degrees (O. Reg. 517/06, s. 11(2) and s. 15(1)). A tank below 43 is failing a standard, not underperforming.
  • A second failure in one season. You have paid for the repair once already. Add the first invoice to the second before you compare.

Either way, put three lines in the unit file: what failed, which option you took, and the cost per year. That record supports your current-versus-capital treatment if the CRA asks, and after a few turnovers it replaces the rule of thumb with your own numbers.


Back to all articles