A postal code is a mail routing instruction. Canada Post's glossary says so directly: postal codes were designed "to help sort mail, both mechanically and manually." That is the job. Describing a neighbourhood is not the job, and the code is poor at it.
This matters because a postal code is the easiest piece of geography to get hold of. It arrives on every application, every lease and every supplier invoice. So it ends up standing in for location in comp sets, service areas and map pins, where it does not hold up.
What the six characters mean
The code splits in two, and the halves are not the same kind of thing.
The first three characters are the forward sortation area. Canada Post describes the FSA as three characters that "represent a geographic area." That half is area-shaped.
The last three are the local delivery unit. Canada Post describes these as characters that "represent a specific point or set of points of call found in the Forward Sortation Area." Points of call, not an area.
Canada Post's addressing guidelines go further. In urban areas the last three characters may indicate a specific city block, which Canada Post defines as one side of a street between two intersecting streets, or a single building, or sometimes a large-volume mail receiver. In rural areas, the last three characters together with the FSA identify a specific rural community.
Read that range again. One full code can mean a single tower. Another can mean an entire rural community. Both are six characters, and nothing in the format tells you which one you are holding.
A map pin hides how it was made
Geocoding turns an address into coordinates. Every serious geocoder also returns a quality flag beside those coordinates, and most software shows you the pin and discards the flag.
Google's Geocoding API publishes four levels, and the definitions are worth knowing because they are the vocabulary most tools borrow:
- ROOFTOP is "a precise geocode" for which the service has "location information accurate down to street address precision."
- RANGE_INTERPOLATED is "an approximation (usually on a road) interpolated between two precise points (such as intersections)." The documentation adds that interpolated results "are generally returned when rooftop geocodes are unavailable for a street address."
- GEOMETRIC_CENTER is "the geometric center of a result such as a polyline (for example, a street) or polygon (region)."
- APPROXIMATE means the result "is approximate."
There is a separate flag for the other failure mode. A result marked partial_match "indicates that the geocoder did not return an exact match for the original request," and Google suggests checking the request for misspellings or an incomplete address.
So a pin sitting neatly on your listing map can be the midpoint of a street segment, the centre of a whole street, or the centre of a region. On a short urban block that error is metres. On a long rural road, or a street that runs along a municipal boundary, it is enough to place your unit in the wrong jurisdiction.
Three ways this goes wrong
Using a code as a comp set
"Rents in that postal code run about this much" sounds specific and often is not, because the code may cover one building. CMHC's Rental Market Survey samples urban areas with populations of 10,000 or more and publishes at the census metropolitan area level. Postal codes are not one of its reporting geographies. If a comp came from a code, say so, and say how many buildings sat inside it.
Mixing the FSA with the full code
The FSA is the half that behaves like an area, so grouping at the FSA level is defensible. The full code is not a smaller, sharper version of the same idea. Google's API carries a field called postcode_localities, which it says is present only when the result is a postal code that contains multiple localities. One code, several localities, built into the response format because it happens often enough to need a field.
Treating a pin as verification
A pin means the geocoder found something plausible for the text you sent it. It is not confirmation that the unit exists, that the unit number is right, or that the building is the one in your photos. Each of those needs its own check.
The pass to run on your own listings
- Export every active listing with the full civic address, including the unit designator and the municipality rather than the mailing city.
- Geocode the list and keep the precision flag beside each result, not only the coordinates.
- Split the rooftop matches from everything else. The rooftop set needs nothing further.
- For the rest, fix the input before blaming the geocoder: street type, direction, unit designator and correct municipality.
- Re-run, then check whatever still fails against satellite imagery and move the pin by hand.
- Write down which addresses you moved by hand, because the next import will quietly undo them.
One habit is worth keeping on top of all that. When you quote a location in writing, to an owner, a lender or a prospect, name the geography you used: the census metropolitan area, the survey zone, the census tract, or a boundary you can state in street names. A postal code is a good way to get mail to a building. It is a weak way to tell anyone where that building sits.
